How much disclosure does the public need? I tend to believe that too much is better than not enough.
I've been watching a story related to this issue unfold in Oregon. Entire government bodies are resigning out there because folks do not want to fill out disclosure forms that reveal intimate details of their financial lives. These are often small-town commissioners who make little to nothing for working long hours to do the public's business.
Al's Morning Meeting reader Karen Hutchinson-Talaski, a staff writer at
The Hermiston (Ore.) Herald, dropped me a note and links
to her paper's work, saying:
Due to new ethics rules in Oregon, anyone who is on a planning commission, city council, a mayor or city manager -- and the governor, legislators, lobbyists, etc. -- must complete a statement of economic interest.
What makes the story interesting is that for 34 years, 98 cities and six counties did not have to complete the form until now. Because the form asks for names of relatives over 18 who do not live with the government official, many people are balking at disclosing the information. Plus, every quarter, another form is to be completed regarding honoraria and monies given for trips, etc.
So far, three planning commissioners and a city councilor have resigned from Umatilla, Ore.; a planning commissioner has resigned from Hermiston, Ore.; the mayor and mayor pro tem resigned from the Irrigon, Ore., city council; plus around the state, planning commissioners and city councilors have resigned practically en masse. In Elgin, Ore., the entire planning commission resigned a couple of weeks ago. This week, the mayor and the entire city council resigned. All because these folks do not want to complete the forms and disclose what they consider information which is none of the government's business. Many of these towns who are struggling with resignations have never had to complete the SEI (statement of economic interest) forms.
How does this affect small towns where the pool of willing volunteers is small? In Irrigon, because the planning commission does not have a quorum, no business can take place and their city's charter does not take into account what would happen if there were no planning commission.
Here are the Oregon Ethics Commission's
statutes and rules and the
forms officials must fill out (see the two items at the end of the list).
QUOTE: Public Servants Quit Rather Than Disclose Finances How much...