Poynter Online
Go


Top Story

'Going Deep' with Sports Illustrated's Gary Smith
Most Recent Articles
Most E-mailed
Recent Comments
Recent Tags
Community Activity

Poynter Training
Poynter Seminars
Small, in-person training experiences.
News University
Today's most popular courses on NewsU, Poynter's e-learning site for journalists.
Webinars
Our online classroom is just a click away. Learn more.
All Webinars

Writing Tools

Home > Writing Tools
Tools: Text Sizeor, Print, RSSRSS, Subscribe via e-mail
Roy Clark
Roy Peter Clark provides tools for your writing toolbox.
PoynterGroups.
Find and join conversations about Reporting, Writing & Editing.


HELP ROY WRITE HIS NEW BOOK


THE GLAMOUR OF GRAMMAR:
A painless and practical guide to the elements of language.
Read all "Glamour of Grammar" posts.


ASK A WRITING QUESTION

 
Fifty Writing Tools: Quick List and Audio Tips
Writing Tools: The Musical

PODCASTS
Listen to Q&A about the blog

Journalism: The Democratic Craft

Coaching Writers

America's Best Newspaper Writing

The Changing South of Gene Patterson: Journalism and Civil Rights, 1960-1968

The Values and Craft of American Journalism

ALSO BY ROY PETER CLARK
Poynter articles
Advice from Dr. Ink
Three Little Words
The Honest Writer



Writing by Accident
A favorite literary anecdote concerns the efforts of Irish author James Joyce to complete his final opus "Finnegans Wake." The book, filled with elaborate multi-lingual puns and stream of consciousness, proved rough going for Joyce, whose health and eyesight were failing. He was aided by young admirers, including Samuel Beckett, who was willing to take dictation from the master.

I remember this anecdote from way back in my college days, and found it repeated on the Web site anecdotage.com:

Once or twice Joyce dictated a bit of "Finnegans Wake" to Samuel Beckett, though dictation did not work very well for him; in the middle of one such session there was a knock at the door which Beckett didn't hear. Afterwards he read back what he had written and Joyce said, "What's that 'Come in'?" "Yes, you said that," said Beckett. Joyce thought for a moment, then said, "Let it stand."

I thought of this moment after a creative mistake crept into my copy. Describing the early futility of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, I made fun of their old uniforms. The color of those classic unis is most often described as "creamsicle orange."  Now for kids my age, a Creamsicle is a classic frozen treat, first cousin to the Popsicle and Fudgesicle (pronounced fudgicle).

As I typed the phrase, two mistakes appeared. First, I unconsciously misspelled the word, adding a 'k': creamsickle. Then my finger must have slipped because when I reviewed the text, it came out "creamsickly." I corrected it immediately, then stopped and mulled it over. "Creamsickly orange?"  Why not?  "Let it stand," I retorted when my editor, Scott Libin, asked me if I had meant to write it that way.

I can think of one other such mistake, when instead of writing "gazillion dollars," I wrote "godzillion dollars." This mistake gave the phrase the connotation of a monstrous amount of money destroying everything in its path, so I let it stand.

I lean toward the conclusion that such mistakes are not mistakes at all, but flares sent up by the unconscious side of the brain. I'm not talking about Freudian slips or simple malapropisms, but something even deeper, a bubbling cauldron of creativity that shoots up a stream of hot goo when we least expect it.

Have any of you, faithful readers, been seized by such creative mistakes?  If so, let us know. 



Posted by Roy Clark 10:58 PM Aug 20, 2007
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Username
Password
New User? Signup Now
Poynter Careers