Poynter Online
Go


Top Story

'Going Deep' with Sports Illustrated's Gary Smith
Most Recent Articles
Most E-mailed
Recent Comments
Recent Tags
Community Activity

Poynter Training
Poynter Seminars
Small, in-person training experiences.
News University
Today's most popular courses on NewsU, Poynter's e-learning site for journalists.
Webinars
Our online classroom is just a click away. Learn more.
All Webinars

Romenesko

Home > Romenesko
Tools: Text Sizeor, Print, RSSRSS, Subscribe via e-mail
Jim Romenesko
Your daily fix of media industry news, commentary, and memos.
Radar Online
Greenhouse
Retired New York Times Supreme Court reporter Linda Greenhouse recalls the 1989 NOW march brouhaha:
Len Downie, over at the Washington Post -- who of course believes that you shouldn't even vote -- Len learned that some of his reporters had also been at the march and he started railing against this. Some of my friends at the Post said, 'well, what's the big deal? Over at the Times, Linda marched, and it was completely in the open and nobody said anything about it.' At that point Eleanor Randolph, who had the press beat at the Washington Post, called Max Frankel to say, 'Well, what about this?' Because here at the Post, our executive editor takes a dim view of this. Well, Max was not going to be "out-ethiced" by Len Downie. And so he said, 'Well, this is terrible, this violates all kinds of rules.' Which, actually, it didn't. So he came down on me. He made Howell [Raines] call me in and read me some kind of riot act.
PLUS: More Greenhouse memories.
Posted at 3:40 PM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Letters updated
3:48 p.m. ET


More puzzlers
From Jay Rosen.
(Romenesko Letters)

POSTED THURSDAY
Royko film
To be based on three columns.
(Wisconsin SJ)

Losing a home
One journo's experience.
(CJR)

Newsweek's Palin cover
Explained.
(LAT Blogs)

LAT publisher's "treason" remark
Prompts Fake LAT post.
(notthelatimes.com)

Press too tough on Palin?
Many say yes.
(People-press.org)

POSTED WEDNESDAY
Okrent's HuffPost piece
Background story.
(Portfolio.com)

People mag's Newman book
"Leaves a sour taste in my mouth."
(Folio)

 

E-mail Romenesko
Send letters, memos,
and feedback.


ABOUT ROMENESKO

PoynterGroups.
Find and join conversations about Romenesko and Leadership & Management.




POPULAR TOPICS


USA Today will cost $1 beginning Dec. 8
Associated Press
USAT logo
The 25 cent increase could affect USA Today more than the Wall Street Journal and New York Times, which raised prices over the summer, because USA Today gets a greater share of its circulation through single-copy sales, says AP's Anick Jesdanun
Posted at 2:41 PM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Reporter who broke MySpace suicide story wins a Lee Excellence in News award
Lee Enterprises release
Steve Pokin, who uncovered a MySpace hoax that led to a 12-year-old girl's suicide, is one of five Lee Enterprises Excellence in News winners. The others are: the Arizona Daily Star (social promotion in schools), North County Times (wildfires coverage), St. Louis Post-Dispatch ("Free to Flee"), and the Provo Daily Herald ("Brady, the Greatest Gift.") || PLUS: More winners.
Posted at 2:28 PM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Gannett newsrooms' mantra is write for online, update for print
PBS MediaShift
"Everything is thought of for immediacy and getting it out the door," says Gannett digital content veep Jennifer Carroll. She answers Mark Glaser's questions about the chain's two-year-old Informative Centers initiative.
Posted at 1:40 PM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Judge tells media, Minnesota officials to reach exit polling compromise
Star Tribune | MinnPost.com
TV networks and the Associated Press have sued Minnesota to stop enforcement of an election day anti-loitering law, saying it would make exit poll interviews virtually impossible. A federal judge on Thursday told lawyers for the state and news orgs to come up with a compromise by Friday or he'll make a ruling. || Also in Minnesota: Sen. Norm Coleman won't let two left-leaning news orgs cover his press conference.
Posted at 1:23 PM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Keller: We weren't prodded to run Obama-Ayers story
Politico.com
"We've reported the Ayers relationship before, and we had it on our 'to do' list for a while to take a more comprehensive look," Times editor Bill Keller tells Michael Calderone. "When the McCain campaign began to make it a major focal point of ads and stump speeches, we decided the time was right."
Posted at 12:45 PM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Claim: Alaska press corps was too easy on Palin
Columbia Journalism Review
palin
That comes from a former Palin administration official, who adds: "I think if you look at all the national stories, and compare it to her governor's race or when she was governor, it's been impossible not to notice. We didn't hear about the librarian. We didn't hear about the rape kits. We didn’t hear about the Wasilla earmarks." Ex-Alaska politico Andrew Halcro notes that "in the last four weeks, the state has gotten to know more about Sarah Palin then in the last twelve years. It's almost become an embarrassment."
Posted at 12:33 PM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Hearst Magazines folds Cosmogirl
Portfolio.com
The December issue will be the last. Jeff Bercovici notes Cosmogirl is the second Hearst title to fold this year; Quick & Simple went over the summer.
Posted at 11:55 AM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
AP institutes hiring freeze, says it's on "solid financial footing"
Romenesko Misc.
AP says it's in good shape, "thanks to modest revenue growth and responsible expense management over the past few years, which have resulted in a positive cash flow." But, a memo to staff adds, "as the economy falters, it is imperative that we keep spending in line with revenue." A hiring freeze was instituted this week.
Posted at 9:55 AM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
How can human editors compete with an algorithm?
Publishing2.com
It's hard to do with the old go-it-alone model of journalism, says Scott Karp. "But they can compete through COLLABORATION. Digg has proven that collaborative human editorial effort can cover a massive amount of territory on the web. Imagine if journalists and news orgs brought together their combined editorial intelligence, their combined news judgment."
Posted at 9:24 AM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Recent Comments:
Here's how. How can human editors compete with an algorithm? Surprise. A... More.
Read All Comments (1 comments)
Philly Daily News tells The Daily Beast to change its logo
Philadelphia Daily News
The Philadelphia Daily News' cease-and-desist letter to Tina Brown demands that she stop using her logo for The Daily Beast, which is "virtually identical in shape, color, font and style to our own Daily News logo."
Posted at 9:01 AM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Star-Ledger has too many volunteering for buyouts
New York Post
Keith J. Kelly reports there were 409 volunteers for the Star-Ledger's buyout package; the paper said it would accept up to 230. || Editor & Publisher: Indianapolis Star union says the paper should have asked for volunteers before laying off staffers.
Posted at 8:37 AM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
US journalists released after detention in Syria
New York Times
Holli Chmela, 27, and Taylor Luck, 23, are on their way back to Jordan. The couple, who had been detained for crossing into Syria "illegally, with the help of a smuggler," work for the Jordan Times.
Posted at 8:15 AM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Food mags cater to readers' new penny-pinching ways
Women's Wear Daily
Food & Wine's November issue includes "A Thrifty Cook's Guide to (Almost) Free Ingredients," while in an upcoming Bon Appetit story on stylish dinner parties, "instead of calling for osetra caviar, which costs $400 for less than 2 oz., we start out with American spoonfish caviar at $49 for 2 oz.," says editor-in-chief Barbara Fairchild.
Posted at 7:54 AM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Tampa Tribune retools again after readers complain about single news section
TampaBay.com | Nick Bergus | Tampa Tribune
The "new" Tribune debuted just Monday. Executive editor Janet Coats tells her staff: "The multiple section habit is deeply engrained. It's clear that trying to change that habit through a single news section is not something readers are going to accept. || Coats tells readers: "We've listened carefully to what you've told us, and we're responding."
Posted at 7:36 AM Oct 10, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
"I disagree that us old farts can't be leaders into the new era," says ex-Spokane editor
Online Journalism Review
Former Spokesman-Review editor Steven A. Smith, 58, responds to David Westphal's question: Are veteran editors the best people to lead newsrooms to a digital future? "My colleagues at the recent Knight Digital Media Center conference are innovators and leaders," he writes in the OJR comments section. "They know what must be done and their years of experience and craft knowledge actually enhance their ability to drive change."
Posted at 5:06 PM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Coleman: I won't respond to bloggers' posts
MinnPost.com
Coleman
Sen. Norm Coleman declined to respond to a Pioneer Press reporter's question about Ken Silverstein's Harpers.org post ("Sen. Coleman Gets by with a Little Help From His Friends"), saying that "there are very awful things that are said about people on blogs. And the idea to make it a legitimate story is something … I just don't respond to it." David Brauer notes that after three days, "the Coleman camp has knocked down precisely zero of Silverstein's assertions."
Posted at 3:48 PM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Proposed LAT redesign isn't as dramatic as Chicago Tribune's revamp
LAObserved.com
With the redesign, the Times is considering doing away with the Times staff writer byline and datelines, to be replaced by a credit line that reads "Reporting from Baghdad" or wherever. "That's kind of amusing," writes Kevin Roderick, "because Tribune innovations czar Lee Abrams got panned for admitting that he didn't understand how datelines work and, incredibly, well into his tenure did not realize that his papers had live reporters in danger's way in Iraq."
Posted at 3:04 PM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Why do some journalistic conflicts become semi-scandals, while others go unnoticed?
Boston Phoenix
Adam Reilly raises the question and writes: "The fact is, the press still ignores or minimizes potential conflicts of interest far more often than it should -- especially those involving high-stakes stories and high-profile journalists. Take, for example, the ongoing awkwardness involving NBC's Andrea Mitchell," who is married to Alan Greenspan. || CJR: NYT "absolutely unloads" on Greenspan. || Radar: An "extraordinary takedown of Greenspan."
Posted at 1:44 PM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Additional items for October 9, 2008
> Tharp promoted to executive editor at Merced Sun-Star
> WSJ plays a leading role in biz leaders' economic summit
> Anchorage Daily News praised for Troopergate coverage
> American City Business Journals to merge two CA papers
> Can a mid-size or major daily paper exist without AP?
> SI Advance gets 1,500 complaints about dropped TV book
Posted at 1:40 PM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
What NYT's Brooks really thinks about Palin
Editor & Publisher | Huffington Post | Slate
Brooks
Sarah Palin "represents a fatal cancer to the Republican party" and she is "absolutely not" ready to be president or vice president, Times columnist David Brooks said at an Atlantic-mag sponsored event. (Watch the video.) Greg Mitchell points out that Brooks has yet to share those views with his Times readers. || Chris Wilson: Palin has been the most blogged-about of the four candidates.
Posted at 1:19 PM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Recent Comments:
It really does seem ... ... as though we're eventually going to come to the... More.
Read All Comments (4 comments)
An alternative to scrapping the Monday paper
Reflections of a Newsosaur
Alan Mutter got a call from a pal at a large metro daily who asked if killing the Monday paper would be a good idea. "How about trying something less drastic, more creative and potentially far more profitable?" Mutter responded. Focus on sports, for example. One of his ideas: "Turning the Monday paper from an ordinary broadsheet into a free-distribution tabloid, featuring not only the newspaper’s best staff-written sports coverage but also the cream of the user-generated content from the website."
Posted at 12:45 PM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Recent Comments:
Here's another option to dropping Monday Here's another option to dropping Monday: http://www.brasstacksdesign.com/save_monday_edition.htm More.
Read All Comments (1 comments)
Is it wrong for a food critic to hire local chefs to cater her wedding?
Atlanta Creative Loafing
Ken Edelstein criticizes Journal-Constitution restaurant critic Meredith Ford Goldman for using Atlanta-area chefs at her wedding reception. He writes: "The situation brings up so many conflict-of-interest issues that it's hard to imagine how they could have been overlooked by Goldman or, just as importantly, by her editors." Goldman points out that she disclosed everything in a story about her wedding feast, and notes that Creative Loafing's dining critic is married to a chef.
Posted at 12:13 PM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Recent Comments:
Why stop there? Should fashion reporters wear clothes? Or should technology writers own... More.
Read All Comments (1 comments)
Critic: When you think of Fox News, take some advice from Bart Simpson
Boston Globe
foxnews
"Don't have a cow, man," writes former Boston Globe TV and theater critic Ed Siegel. "Although it's easy to dismiss the Fox News Channel as the broadcast wing of the Republican Party, critics continually turn a blind eye to a basic virtue of FNC: It's really pretty entertaining."
Posted at 11:34 AM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Recent Comments:
Sorry, I disagree Gary, I disagree. And for one simple reason which no... More.
Read All Comments (6 comments)
Houston Chronicle lays off ten after buyouts goal isn't reached
Wall Street Journal
The Hearst paper cut 90 positions -- 25 from the newsroom -- which is about 5% of its staff. || FishbowlDC: Those laid off include White House correspondent Julie Mason and national political correspondent Bennett Roth.
> Houston Chronicle editorial writer gives money to candidate
Posted at 10:45 AM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
"Washington City Paper Files for Chapter 86 Content Bankruptcy Protection"
Washington City Paper
That's the headline on City Paper's release about its decision "to file voluntary petitions for content reorganization, citing diminished staff and the flagging confidence of its readers." The joke -- er...release continues: "During this time, Washington City Paper will continue to publish under court protection from its readers, who have wielded an unreasonable degree of power over the publication’s future." || Here's the "court filing" and bankruptcy FAQ.
Posted at 9:40 AM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
San Diego Union-Tribune says seven groups are eyeing the paper
San Diego Union-Tribune
They are Tribune, MediaNews, Black Press, Stephens Media, Yucaipa Cos., Platinum Equity, and KUSI owner Michael D. McKinnon. The Copley Press paper was put up for sale in July.
Posted at 8:45 AM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Columbian considers Chapter 11 bankruptcy, will move back to its old offices
Columbian
The Columbian plans to relocate its operations to former offices in downtown Vancouver, Washington so it can generate more revenue from a new building constructed by publisher Scott Campbell and his wife. Campbell says the company is trying to negotiate a new loan with its lender or will seek temporary Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection from creditors.
> Press-Register donates $50,000 in property
Posted at 7:38 AM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Two US journalists traveling in Lebanon appear to be missing
New York Times
Holli Chmela, 27, and Taylor Luck, 23, arrived in Lebanon from Jordan on Sept. 29 -- they've been working at the Jordan Times -- and haven't been heard from since Oct. 1. They were expected back at the newspaper on Saturday. || UPDATE: Syria says it's holding the journalists for illegally crossing the border from Lebanon.
Posted at 7:22 AM Oct 9, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
McClatchy DC bureau chief praises "remarkable CEOs" Pruitt and Ridder
Nieman Watchdog
John Walcott said as he accepted the first I.F. Stone Medal for Journalistic Independence: "Tony Ridder and Gary Pruitt have come in for a lot of criticism in recent years, but let me say this as plainly as I can: First Tony and now Gary have never been anything but supportive of the journalism that we've tried to do in the Knight Ridder and McClatchy Washington Bureaus. Not once -- not one time -- has either of them second-guessed our editorial decisions or our stories, even when bigger and better known news organizations were reporting the opposite."
Posted at 3:34 PM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
New York mag's Spitzer cover wins at AMC
New York Post | AdAge.com
Spitzercov
The judges who awarded it Cover of the Year at the American Magazine Conference liked the "directness, humor and simplicity" and noted that "the cover required no headlines. The image succeeds all by itself." New York's Eliot Spitzer cover was also cited for best news cover and best coverline. || More from AMC: Google CEO Eric Schmidt complains that the Internet is fast becoming a "cesspool" where false information thrives.
Posted at 3:06 PM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
KU grad's piece on depression wins Rolling Stone's College Journalism Competition
Daily Kansan
Thor Nystrom used his medical records, police records, personal diary, interviews with family and his own recollections to write an account of what he calls his descent into the "depths of hell." (How about buying this Brainerd, Minn. native a cup of coffee the next time you're in the Midwest, David Carr?) Nystrom, a 2008 University of Kansas grad, wins $2,500 in Rolling Stone's contest.
Posted at 2:29 PM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Report: Four newspaper companies show interest in San Diego Union-Tribune
Voice of San Diego
They are, according to Randy Dotinga, the New York Times Co., MediaNews Group, Tribune Co. and Black Press, Ltd. Also, some San Diego businesspeople are said to have their eyes on the Union-Tribune, he reports.
Posted at 1:44 PM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
FYI: A one-hour network newscast is unlikely
New York Times
Some wonder if there's a need for a network evening newscast, while NYT reader Roni Stein asks if there will ever be a one-hour network news report. Unlikely, says Times reporter Jacques Steinberg. He turns to ex-TV news exec Richard Wald, who points out that "cable news stations provide all the news the news junkies need." || PLUS: NYTer Bill Carter's ten favorite TV shows.
Posted at 12:39 PM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Are veteran editors the best people to be leading newsrooms to a digital future?
Online Journalism Review
They're handicapped by their investment in a fast-disappearing past and are sometimes slow to see how quickly the information revolution is occurring, says David Westphal, who recently left McClatchy's Washington bureau to join USC Annenberg. "Will young journalists with no investment in the past (for good and ill) be better choices?"
Posted at 11:42 AM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Recent Comments:
Alex's comment I liked the dowsing story. More.
Read All Comments (2 comments)
New York Times to shutter IHT.com
Forbes.com | Content Bridges
NYTimes.com general manager Vivian Schiller insists that shuttering the International Herald Tribune site is about growth, not cost savings. She hopes tying NYTimes.com and IHT.com together will increase the Times' traffic and give it more content against which to sell ads. || Ken Doctor: The move makes a lot of sense.
Posted at 10:57 AM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
"Google's such a natural home for Holovaty"
Valleywag
It may be, but Adrian Holovaty says he hasn't struck a deal with the search giant. "If Holovaty does land at Google, expect him to transform Google News into a site that's more of a database of information than a news archive," writes Owen Thomas. "He's long been critical of the newspaper industry's focus on stories, rather than information."
Posted at 10:47 AM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Recent Comments:
Misleading To say "hasn't struck a deal with the search giant"... More.
Read All Comments (1 comments)
Denton: "I'll definitely read The Daily Beast, but..."
New York Times
Nick Denton wonders how many others will regularly visit Tina Brown's new website. "The design is lively," says Gawker's founder, but "it has to be simpler to work." Brown tells David Carr: "We have heard from a lot of people who love what we came up with, but we are tweaking and refining even as we speak."
> Russo: TDB is a thematic relative of Brown's defunct Talk
Posted at 9:56 AM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Star-Ledger drivers OK deal, paper won't be sold or closed
Newark Star-Ledger
Star-Ledger truck drivers ratified a new labor agreement Tuesday night, ensuring the paper will not be sold or closed. "I'm thrilled The Star-Ledger will remain part of our family," says Donald Newhouse, president of Advance Publications, which has owned the paper since 1935. || Wall Street Journal: Star-Ledger and LAT slice costs further.
> Read Star-Ledger publisher George Arwady's memo to staff
Posted at 9:30 AM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
The long, slow bleed of reporters out of Albany has become more like a geyser
New York Times
The New York Sun, which folded last week, was the fifth paper to leave the New York Capitol press room in less than two years, reports Jeremy W. Peters. The Staten Island Advance, Syracuse Post-Standard, Schenectady Daily Gazette and Middletown Times Herald-Record have all removed their statehouse correspondents from the Capitol since the beginning of 2007.
> Star-Ledger Statehouse bureau loses big in buyouts
Posted at 8:58 AM Oct 8, 2008
Tools:
Comment, e-mail, Permalink, Share
Lewis leaves Portfolio, NYT Mag for Vanity Fair
New York Observer
Michael Lewis has told Vanity Fair that he'll drop his New York Times Magazine and Portfolio contracts and sign exclusively with them, reports John Koblin. He writes: "It's an incredible get for [VF editor Graydon] Carter: Vanity Fair gets perhaps the most important financial journalist in the country to move from Conde Nast's only financial title."
Posted at 8:26 AM Oct 8, 2008