Editor’s note: This story contains references and links to graphic images and videos.
An Instagram video seeking to disprove reports of violence in the Oct. 7 Gaza attack on Israel claimed that accounts of a mass shooting at an Israeli music festival are false.
“Two-hundred-fifty people were killed at a concert: False,” the video’s narrator said in the Oct. 10 post as words stating the same appeared on the screen.
“The only videos we have seen are people running away from the concert,” he continued. “There isn’t a single video or photo suggesting that 250 people were killed at a concert or that a mass shooting took place.”
But that’s wrong.
(Screenshot/Instagram)
This post was flagged as part of Meta’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram.)
In a large-scale assault against Israel, Hamas militants opened fire at the Tribe of Nova Festival near the Gaza-Israel border on Oct. 7. About 3,500 people attended the two-day trance music festival, billed as an event celebrating “friends, love and infinite freedom.” People had been dancing through the night when the rockets began firing right before dawn.
Israeli rescue service Zaka said 260 bodies were recovered at the festival site. Some Israelis were taken hostage. Many festival attendees hid in nearby orchards and bushes waiting to get rescued, and survivors said Hamas militants were hunting them down for hours as they tried to flee.
Heads of state also confirmed the attack and deaths. The leaders of France, Germany, Italy, the United Kingdom and the U.S. issued an Oct. 9 statement condemning the slaughter of “over 200 young people enjoying a music festival.” In an Oct. 10 speech, President Joe Biden condemned the massacre of young people attending the festival “to celebrate peace.”
MORE FROM POYNTER: How to avoid misinformation about the war in Gaza
And contrary to the video’s claims, there are numerous images and videos showing the shootings at the festival grounds.
The Instagram video claimed that the only videos from the concert show people running away. As part of its evidence, it shows a clip of people running in the desert. But in a fuller video clip from that moment gunshots can be heard in the background.
Dashcam video, media and concertgoers also captured videos showing lifeless bodies by a van, men shooting people around a car, and a Hamas fighter shooting at a car escaping from the festival grounds.
Another video shows people running across a field while gunshots are being fired.
CNN Chief International Correspondent Clarissa Ward reported that the government released a photo of scores of body bags in a tent, their identities yet to be determined.
The Instagram video also sought to discount two other reports about the conflict that have captured attention — that 40 babies had been beheaded and that people had been raped.
The report about babies being beheaded originated with a reporter who said she heard the allegations from Israeli soldiers. Israeli Defense Forces has not confirmed this report, nor have U.S. officials. Hamas has denied it. There have been a number of state reports, however, about violence against babies and children. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office shared Oct. 12 photos of babies it said were “murdered and burned” by Hamas.
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken said during an Oct. 12 press conference that he had viewed gruesome war images from Israel and they included documentation of “an infant riddled with bullets.”
When asked about the authenticity of the images of dead children shared by Netanyahu, U.S. White House National Security Council Strategic Communications Coordinator John Kirby said Oct. 12, “I don’t think we’re in the business of having to validate or approve those kinds of images. They’re from the prime minister of Israel, and we have no reason to doubt their authenticity.”
Regarding whether people were raped during the attack, Netanyahu on Oct. 11 described atrocities committed by Hamas and said men and women were “burned alive” and young women were “raped and slaughtered.” An Israeli official also said women were raped. Biden referenced rape as well in his comments.
There is ample evidence, including numerous videos and photos, and official reports substantiating that 260 people were killed at an Israeli music festival during the Hamas attack Oct. 7. We rate the claim that it did not happen Pants on Fire.
More from Poynter on the Israel-Hamas war
- How to avoid misinformation about the war in Gaza
- When journalists find demonstrators’ views personally offensive
- Amid images and news of actual war, false and misleading claims about Israel-Hamas thrive
- How standards editors are sorting through graphic images from Israel and Gaza
- The basics on Israel, Gaza, Palestine and Hamas for local journalists
- Journalists are among the casualties in the war between Israel and Hamas
- Journalists, nonstop coverage of war and violence affects your mental health
PolitiFact Staff Writer Sara Swann contributed to this report.
This fact check was originally published by PolitiFact, which is part of the Poynter Institute. See the sources for this fact check here.
