“Collision of Power” by retired Washington Post executive editor Marty Baron has only been available for three days, but Baron’s promotional tour has unearthed what feels like enough revelations about Post owner Jeff Bezos, media coverage of former President Donald Trump and the state of journalism to fill another book.
In a wide-ranging Q&A with Seattle Times Save the Press Initiative editor Brier Dudley, Baron spoke about the effects of Bezos’ 2013 purchase of the Post and how it “instilled a lot of hope” in staff. The outlet succeeded in the years since, Baron said, because it “delivered something that people really valued” — it was at the forefront of holding Trump accountable for his words and actions.
“I talk in the book about how we came up with (the slogan) ‘Democracy Dies in Darkness.’ As Bezos said, this is an idea people want to belong to, not a newspaper they want to subscribe to. The idea was shining light in dark corners, holding government to account, holding our representatives to high standards and all of that. People were willing to get behind that and help pay for it,” Baron said. “That’s what we needed.
“That’s a part of what local news organizations need to do, in terms of keeping a watchful eye on the police and city council, state government, school boards, you name it,” he continued. “And they need to be providing people real value day in and day out, information about their own communities, that people say ‘I would really miss this if this were gone, every day I’m getting something of value here,’ so that they’re willing to pay for it.”
Given that Trump’s ongoing candidacy for president is a “threat to democracy and the country’s framework of government,” CNN senior media reporter Oliver Darcy asked Baron if news organizations should “remain totally neutral” when covering the former president. (Baron has defended a traditional standard of “objectivity” in journalism during a time when critics have questioned its value.)
“There’s evidence aplenty that Trump is an aspiring authoritarian,” Baron said. “He has talked openly about suspending the Constitution. He has talked openly about using the military to suppress legitimate protests. He has suggested that someone like Mark Milley should be executed. He has called for prosecuting NBC for treason. He continues to use language that excuses, and is likely to incite, violence against his political opponents. He has called for shutting down the government as a way to end federal prosecutions directed at him. These are unmistakable signals of the sort of presidency he intends to have, and the coverage needs to make that clear. That’s just being accurate, based on a mountain of evidence — which, again, we need to show in full.”
CNN lead Washington anchor Jake Tapper questioned Baron about the Post’s 2020 suspension of Felicia Sonmez. Shortly after basketball star Kobe Bryant was killed in a helicopter crash, Sonmez tweeted a link to a 2016 Daily Beast story that recalled allegations of rape against Bryant dating back to 2003. Sonmez was subsequently suspended.
“First of all, I can’t think of anything more journalistic — in the sense that we are the ones that are supposed to bring up the most uncomfortable truths to the public — than that tweet,” Tapper said. “And second of all, I bet there were millions of rape survivors and sexual assault survivors that saw her tweet and thought, ‘Thank God somebody out there is speaking for me.’”
Baron said when the Post publishes obituaries on controversial people, they “always bring up the moments of dishonor.” But, he said, “We also assign certain people to do those kinds of stories. We don’t expect anybody in the newsroom to decide to throw out commentary as they wish, whenever they wish, in whatever manner they wish.”
“It was just a tweet,” Tapper said.
“It wasn’t just a tweet,” Baron responded. “It was a tweet at a particular moment in a particular way that created an enormous reaction where people focused on us at The Washington Post as opposed to focusing on our coverage of Kobe Bryant.”
Baron spoke more about his views on social media in an interview with former Financial Times editor Lionel Barber and Prospect editor Alan Rusbridger on their new “Media Confidential” podcast.
“I think there was a moment where I lost a good portion of the newsroom … they wanted the freedom to express themselves on social media, to share their feelings, their reactions,” Baron said. “They reacted not well to my efforts to enforce our policies and so there was actually quite an uprising. … I did feel that there was a growing chasm between myself and many people on the staff and I was dismayed at that.”
Baron retired from The Washington Post at the end of February 2021. In a Q&A, Los Angeles Times staff writer James Rainey noted that Baron’s accomplishments at the Post included 10 Pulitzer Prizes — to say nothing about the rest of his acclaimed career in journalism.
“So,” Rainey asked, “will you miss it?”
“I was an editor at three different news organizations over the course of 20 years,” Baron said. “It became ever more exhausting, because it’s not just a 24-7 job, it’s a 24-7-every-minute job. And I (increasingly) felt a chasm between how I felt journalism should be practiced and how at least a good number of people on our staff wanted to practice it. I didn’t know that I could really resolve that. … Now, I don’t have to deal with that every single day. I want to move on and do other things. …
“So, no, I don’t miss it.”
By Ren LaForme, managing editor
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette workers mark one-year anniversary of strike
Striking workers at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette are rallying today to mark the one-year anniversary of their work stoppage.
Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) and Rep. Chris Deluzio (D-Pa.) are expected to make an appearance at the rally. A year ago, roughly 80 production, distribution and advertising staff walked off the job in protest of the Post-Gazette’s decision to terminate their health care coverage. Less than two weeks later, roughly 60 journalists also went on strike with their own list of demands. The Post-Gazette strike is the longest newspaper strike in decades.
The paper, which is owned by Block Communications, and the unions last met Sept. 12. Communications Workers of America spokesperson Moira Bulloch wrote in an email that Post-Gazette negotiators verbally agreed to a health care plan from the unions but have refused to sign the participation agreement.
Post-Gazette spokesperson Allison Latcheran wrote in an emailed statement, “We are optimistic that a resolution to the current work stoppage will be found soon and appreciate the Herculean efforts of our employees who continue to work.”
Labor relations between the Post-Gazette and the paper’s unions have been tumultuous. For nearly seven years, the unions and the paper have failed to come to an agreement on a contract. Over the course of the strike, the Post-Gazette has attempted to stop workers from picketing at its facilities, and an altercation between union members and replacement workers earlier in the year led to one person being hospitalized.
By Angela Fu, media business reporter
The Washington Post launches a FOIA column
The Washington Post announced a new column, “Revealing Records,” that will take readers behind the scenes of the newspaper’s work in digging up public records for its reporting.
Anchored by Nate Jones, the Post’s first Freedom of Information Act director, “Revealing Records” will offer a look inside the process of requesting records and the legal battles that ensue.
“We are thrilled to offer this entertaining and educational window into the work we do every day to scrutinize power and empower people,” said Sarah Childress, deputy editor for long-term investigations, in a press release announcing the column.
The column launched this week with quite the exclusive: A request for official White House photographs taken the day Osama bin Laden was killed unearthed a photo of former President Barack Obama laughing at a printed-out meme of himself.
By Annie Aguiar, audience engagement producer
A ‘Daily Show’ departure
NPR TV critic Eric Deggans with the scoop: “Roy Wood Jr. says he’s leaving ‘The Daily Show’ but he doesn’t hold a grudge.”
Wood has been a correspondent on the show for eight years, but because he wasn’t offered the permanent host role, he’s moving on so he can figure out his next move. He told Deggans, “I can’t come up with Plan B while still working with Plan A. The job of correspondent … it’s not really one where you can juggle multiple things. (And) I think eight years is a good run.”
Deggans reports Wood would consider staying if Comedy Central offered him the permanent host job, but in a statement, “The Daily Show” said, “Roy Wood Jr. is a comedic genius and beloved teammate. His insights and hilarity helped us make sense of the 2016 election, the pandemic, and countless hours of Fox News. We thank him for his time with us and can’t wait to see what he does next.”
“The Daily Show” is looking for a replacement for Trevor Noah, who left as host late last year. The show used a variety of guest hosts, including Wood, until it shut down because of the writers strike. Deadline’s Peter White recently reported that the show will return on Oct. 16 and will continue to use guest hosts for the rest of the year. A permanent host is not expected to be named until the start of 2024.
By Tom Jones, senior media writer
Media tidbits and links for your weekend review
- In “The Remaking of The Wall Street Journal,” The New York Times’ Katie Robertson writes about how Emma Tucker, the Journal’s top editor since February, “is moving away from some of the organization’s traditions.” The goal, Robertson reports, “is to add many new online subscribers by delivering readers expertise and ‘distinctive’ journalism.”
- The Associated Press’ David Bauder with “All Trump, all the time? Former president’s legal problems a boon to MSNBC.”
- Nieman Lab’s Sarah Scire with “The Athletic cuts back on local podcasts.”
- Rats! The Wall Street Journal’s Washington, D.C., bureau has a mouse problem. The Journal said “the campaign for a mouse-free office has been in full swing for several weeks now” and, though there is not an infestation, “one mouse is one too many so we are working to say goodbye to all of them as quickly as we can.” The New York Times’ Katie Robertson has the memo.
- Related: The New York Times has been bugged. It’s not what you think. Semafor’s Max Tani reports that “an employee in the New York newsroom drank a cup of coffee with some sort of worm/bug in it, leading the Times to discover an additional bug in one of the office coffee machines.”
- Smart data-driven work from The Washington Post’s Lauren Weber, Dan Diamond and Dan Keating: “How red-state politics are shaving years off American lives.”
- Finally, a harrowing look at how the effects of climate change could redefine — and has already redefined, in many places — American summers. The New York Times’ Julie Bosman with “Why Summers May Never Be the Same.”
- X, the social network formerly known as Twitter, followed through Thursday with plans to remove article headlines and preview text from news articles posted to the site. Links now generate only an image and brief URL. How are newsroom audience teams feeling about the change? This tweet from The Baltimore Banner’s Ben Conarck about sums it up.
More resources for journalists
- Poynter will present Anderson Cooper with its Medal for Lifetime Achievement in Journalism at the Bowtie Ball in Tampa, Florida, on Nov. 18. Get tickets to join the celebration.
- Lead With Influence (Nov. 6-27) (Online Seminar) — Apply by Oct. 13.
- Poynter’s Beat Academy (Webinar series) — Enroll now.
- Poynter ACES Introductory Certificate in Editing (Online) — Enroll now.
Have feedback or a tip? Email Poynter senior media writer Tom Jones at tjones@poynter.org.
The Poynter Report is our daily media newsletter. To have it delivered to your inbox Monday-Friday, sign up here.